What are the disadvantages of germanium over silicon?

While germanium has some advantages over silicon, particularly in terms of its electronic and optical properties, there are several notable disadvantages that have led to silicon being the dominant material in semiconductor applications:

1. Temperature Sensitivity: Germanium has a lower melting point (937°C) compared to silicon (1414°C). This lower melting point translates into a lower maximum operating temperature for germanium devices, making them less suitable for high-temperature applications. Silicon devices can operate at higher temperatures without performance degradation.
2. Cost and Availability: Germanium is more expensive and less abundant than silicon. Silicon is the second most abundant element in the Earth’s crust and is available in almost unlimited quantities as silica or sand. The cost-effectiveness of silicon is significantly better, which makes it more attractive for a wide range of electronic applications.
3. Oxide Quality: Silicon dioxide (SiO2), which forms naturally when silicon is exposed to oxygen, is a superior insulator and can be used effectively as a gate dielectric in silicon-based devices. This oxide layer is thermally stable and forms a strong, high-quality electrical insulator. In contrast, the native oxide of germanium (GeO2) is less stable and provides poorer insulating properties, which can lead to higher leakage currents in semiconductor devices.
4. Doping Precision: Doping processes used in manufacturing semiconductor devices are more mature and controllable for silicon than for germanium. Silicon’s crystal structure and chemical properties allow for more precise and stable incorporation of dopants, which is crucial for achieving the desired electrical characteristics in semiconductors.
5. Chemical Reactivity: Germanium is generally more reactive than silicon, particularly in terms of its susceptibility to oxidation and corrosion. This can make handling and processing more challenging, requiring more protective measures during manufacturing.
6. Integration with Existing Technology: The entire semiconductor industry has standardized around silicon-based technology, which includes not just the semiconductor materials themselves but also the extensive infrastructure for processing silicon wafers, the detailed understanding of silicon’s physical and chemical behavior, and the vast body of design and engineering knowledge. Transitioning to germanium would require substantial changes in equipment and processes, representing a significant barrier.

These factors collectively explain why silicon is more widely used in electronics, despite some of germanium’s superior electronic properties, especially in high-speed applications.

Shapeoptics offers a comprehensive range of materials and advanced equipment for custom and OEM optical components, leveraging over 20 years of expertise in manufacturing lenses, prisms, windows, and more. We utilize high-quality materials like UV and IR grade fused silica, Germanium, and ZnSe, among others. Our state-of-the-art techniques and equipment minimize waste and optimize delivery times. Our in-house capabilities include standard and custom coatings across the UV-NIR spectrum, ensuring high quality and compliance with all industry standards. For precision and reliability in optics, contact Shapeoptics for your next project.